Hello dear
Welcome to New York Pizzeria
**About New York Pizzeria**Located in Cato, NY, New York Pizzeria has become a beloved staple for pizza enthusiasts over the past decade. Renowned for its exceptional quality, the pizzeria serves up mouthwatering pies, featuring a perfectly crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and a delectable balance of tangy sauce and melted cheese. The extensive menu includes not only outstanding pizza but also highly praised wings, particularly the unique Jenny style. The welcoming staff and efficient service ensure a delightful experience, even during busy hours. With rave reviews from locals and visitors alike, New York Pizzeria undeniably stands out as a top destination for pizza lovers.
Inside the Experience
New York Pizzeria
Welcome to New York Pizzeria, a culinary gem nestled at 11376 Main St, Cato, NY 13033. This establishment is not just a pizzeria; it’s a destination for food enthusiasts seeking authentic New York-style pizza and a superb dining experience.
The accolades speak for themselves. As one customer, F W, proclaimed, “The best pizza in the area, bar none.” For over a decade, New York Pizzeria has been a beloved choice for locals and travelers alike. The consistency in delivering an exceptional product is apparent, with rave reviews highlighting the fresh ingredients and dedication to quality.
When you take your first bite of their pizza, you will immediately notice the expertly crafted crust, a perfect balance of golden crispiness on the outside and a soft, chewy texture inside. The sauce strikes a harmonious balance between tangy and savory, while the cheese melts with a delightful stretch that truly embodies the essence of New York pizza. Every topping is generously portioned and bursting with freshness.
But it’s not just about pizza; the menu boasts an array of delectable options. The wings, particularly the "Jenny style" and charbroiled, have garnered enthusiastic praise from patrons like Justin Pierce, who noted they are “some of the best wings I’ve ever had.” Coupled with the signature Jenny sauce, these wings elevate your dining experience to another level.
Customer service is equally impressive. Dallas Rutt shared his satisfaction with the attentive staff and quick service, even during peak hours. This warmth and efficiency make visitors feel valued and welcomed, enhancing the overall ambiance of New York Pizzeria.
As D Thompson enthusiastically stated, “BEST PIZZA I EVER HAD IN LIFE.” These heartfelt endorsements exemplify why making the journey to Cato is worthwhile for anyone serious about their pizza. Whether you're a local resident or passing through, New York Pizzeria is a must-visit. Experience the passion, quality, and flavor that make this establishment truly special. Don't forget to indulge in their wings and signature sauces; you might just discover your new favorite dish!
For a slice of New York that feels like home, or to place an order for pickup, give them a call at +1 315-626-6662. You won’t regret it!
Words from Visitors
Guestbook
“ The best pizza in the area, bar none. I drive out of my way to get pizza there. They have been the best for at least the past 12 years thats when I first tried their pizza. They may have been the best for longer than that... I would bet that they were. And I know that they still are. Subs there are really great as well. Be sure to try the Jenny sauce on the wings. ”
“ I get pizza here pretty regularly and the service is very good. The are often very busy but the wait time is pretty short. Definitely recommend. ”
“ Probably the best pizza within at least 50 miles and has to be at least on par with some of the best in New York when considering how far it is from the city ”
“ I'm a truck driver and here lately I've been picking up in Cato. Finally decided to try this place and to be honest they have some of the best wings I've ever had. The wings, Jenny style and charbroiled were just amazing. The pizza was made with fresh ingredients and just as amazing. The people working that night were real nice. Highly recommend and can't wait to get back there for the wings. ”
“ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Outstanding Pizza & Service! Cato New York Pizzaria is hands down the best spot in town! The pizza is baked to perfection — the crust is golden and crispy on the outside while soft and chewy inside. Their sauce has that perfect balance of tangy and savory, and the cheese melts beautifully with just the right stretch. Every topping tastes fresh and generously portioned. The staff are incredibly friendly and make you feel right at home from the moment you walk in. Service is quick, the place is spotless, and you can tell they truly care about their customers. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering a whole pie for family and friends, you can’t go wrong here. This is authentic New York pizza done right — definitely worth every visit! Cato New York Pizzaria isn’t just about amazing food — it’s about the people behind it. The girls in the back are always cooking it up with care, and you can taste the love in every slice. From the fresh toppings to the perfect crust, it’s true New York pizza right here in town. And let me just say — the owner, Marcia Sherman, is one of the sweetest people you’ll ever meet. She always greets customers with a smile and makes you feel like family. You can tell she puts her heart into this place, and it shows in both the food and the atmosphere. If you’re anywhere near Cato, do yourself a favor and stop in. Support this local gem — you’ll leave full, happy, and already planning your next visit! The only small issue? The space inside can get tight when there are lots of customers. It just shows how popular the place is! Honestly, I’d love to see some outdoor seating so more people could enjoy the food and atmosphere without feeling crowded. Still, the food and the people more than make up for it. This is easily one of the best spots around — worth every visit! ”